🧅 Why do onions make us cry?

Kids Ask · A real kid question, answered · Grades 2–6

The short answer

When you cut an onion, you break open its tiny cells. Chemicals that were kept apart inside each cell mix together and make a new chemical that floats into the air as a gas. When that gas reaches your eyes, it stings them a little, so your eyes make tears to wash it away.

🔪 Inside an onion cell

This is one onion cell, zoomed in a lot. The blue dots are an enzyme (a helper chemical that makes reactions go). The yellow dots are sulfur compounds. Cut the onion, then move the slider to see what happens next.

This is a drawing to show the idea, not a real measurement.

Dig deeper: a chain reaction in four steps

  1. Kept apart. Inside an onion cell, an enzyme is stored in one compartment and a group of sulfur compounds in another (Irwin Goldman, horticulture professor at the University of Wisconsin–Madison).
  2. Mixed by the knife. Cutting breaks the cells open, so the two mix and react.
  3. A gas is made. The reaction makes an irritating gas with a tongue-twister name: syn-propanethial-S-oxide (Library of Congress). Scientists used to blame one enzyme for this. Then in 2002, researchers in Japan found a second enzyme, called lachrymatory-factor synthase, that actually makes the gas. Science changes when new evidence comes in!
  4. Tears to the rescue. The gas floats up to your eyes. It "stimulates the eyes' lachrymal glands so they release tears" (Library of Congress). Lachrymal means "having to do with tears." Your tears wash the stinging chemical away.

Why would an onion do this?

It is the onion's way of protecting itself. Professor Goldman calls it a "chemical defense that onion plants have to protect themselves against insects and microbes." The same reaction also makes chemicals that give onions their strong taste and smell.

Can you cry less?

Yes, a little. Chilling the onion first helps, because "this is an enzyme-mediated process, and low temperatures slow enzymes down" (Goldman). Sweet onions, like Vidalia onions grown in low-sulfur soil, make less of the stinging reaction, so they are milder.

✅ Quick check (3 questions)

🧪 Try this at home: does chilling help?

The adult does all the cutting. You watch from a safe distance. Ask an adult to put one onion in the fridge for a few hours and leave another on the counter. Then the adult cuts each onion the same way, on two different days or at least an hour apart. Each time, the cutter rates how much their eyes sting: 0 (none), 1 (a little), 2 (some) or 3 (a lot). Did the cold onion sting less? One test isn't proof, so try it a few times.

Safety: knives are for grown-ups. Wash your hands after touching onions and never rub your eyes with onion-y fingers.

Sources

We opened and checked each of these pages while writing this one.

Related: Why do we get goosebumps? · Why do we yawn?

More kid questions

❓ All Kids Ask questions