🌲 Why do pinecones open and close?
Kids Ask · A real kid question, answered · Grades 2–6
The short answer
A pinecone's scales open when the air is dry and close when it is wet. Nothing alive has to push them. The scales are made of different kinds of tissue that soak up water differently, so water makes them bend shut and drying makes them bend open again. Opening on dry days lets the seeds fall out and ride the wind. Closing on wet days keeps the seeds tucked safely inside.
🌦️ Rain or shine?
Move the slider from wet to dry and watch the scales. When the cone is open, press Blow wind to see if any seeds float away.
This model moves fast. A real pinecone takes minutes or even hours to open or close.
Dig deeper: a cone that moves by itself
Seeds on the scales
Pine trees have two kinds of cones. "Male pinecones are small and hard to see," and they hold pollen. The woody cones with scales are female cones. They carry the seeds, and their "scales open and close depending on the weather" (Pacific Science Center).
Open in dry weather, closed in wet
"Pinecones open in warm, dry weather to release seeds and close in the cold, damp weather to protect them" (Pacific Science Center). Plant scientists who study Scots pine cones explain the timing: cones open and drop their seeds "under dry conditions when wind dispersal is favored." In other words, dry days are the best days for seeds to ride the wind.
How a scale bends
A scale is built from several kinds of tissue that soak up water and swell in different ways. When water gets in, the scale bends back toward the closed position. When it dries, it bends open again. Scientists call this a hygroscopic movement, which means it is driven by water in the air. It is usually slow, taking "minutes or even hours" (Horstmann and others, Frontiers in Plant Science, 2022).
It even works on fossils
Because the movement comes from the way the scale is built, it keeps working long after a cone falls off the tree. The same scientists say it works "even in millions of years old, coalified cones," which are fossil cones that have turned partly into coal.
Some cones wait for fire
The cones of some kinds of pine stay shut until the heat of a fire, and then they open and release their seeds (New York Botanical Garden). Read more in How do seeds travel?
✅ Quick check (3 questions)
🧪 Try this at home: a pinecone weather station
Find an open pinecone that has already fallen to the ground. Put it in a bowl of water and check on it every 30 minutes. Is it closing? After a few hours, take it out, set it on a paper towel in a dry spot, and check it again the next day. Does it open back up? Draw what you see each time. You have made a pinecone weather station!
For grown-ups: pick up only fallen cones, and only where collecting is allowed. Stay nearby when young children have a bowl of water, and empty it when you are done. Pine sap is sticky, so wash hands afterward.
Sources
We opened and checked each of these pages while writing this one.
- Horstmann, Buchheit, Speck and Poppinga (2022), The cracking of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) cones, Frontiers in Plant Science 13:982756
- Pacific Science Center: Why Do Pinecones Open and Close and How Does That Affect Seeds?
- New York Botanical Garden, Mertz Library: How do plants disperse their seeds?
Related: How do seeds travel? · Why do leaves change color in fall? · Plant Growth Lab