Reading › Reading Passages › Grades 3–4

The Great Garden Debate

FictionWritten for grades 3–4306 wordsPlay script (reader’s theater)

[Characters: MS. OKAFOR, the teacher; JADA; ELI; SAM. Setting: the school garden on a sunny spring morning. One garden bed is empty.]

MS. OKAFOR: Class, this garden bed is ours for the whole spring. We have to agree on what to plant. Who has an idea?

JADA: Pumpkins! Giant ones. We could have a pumpkin contest in the fall.

ELI: Pumpkins take up the whole bed. I want sunflowers. They grow taller than a grown-up, and birds eat the seeds.

SAM: [quietly] What about vegetables we could eat? Like lettuce and carrots. We could make a salad for lunch.

MS. OKAFOR: Sam, can you say that a little louder? Every idea deserves to be heard.

SAM: [louder] Vegetables. We could share a salad with the whole class at the end of the year.

JADA: Salad? [makes a face] Pumpkins are way more exciting.

ELI: Sunflowers are more exciting. You can see them from the street!

MS. OKAFOR: I hear three strong ideas. Let’s ask some questions. When does school end?

SAM: In June.

MS. OKAFOR: And when are pumpkins ready?

JADA: [slowly] In the fall. After school ends. Oh. Nobody would be here to pick them.

ELI: [frowning] Sunflowers might not bloom before June, either. That means the birds would get the seeds and we would never even see the flowers.

SAM: Lettuce grows fast. And carrots don’t need much room.

JADA: [thinking] Okay. What if we plant lettuce and carrots in most of the bed, and save one corner for a sunflower or two? Then the birds get something too.

ELI: I like that. The sunflowers could go in the back so they don’t shade the lettuce.

MS. OKAFOR: Now that is teamwork. Who wants to make the planting map?

ALL: [raising hands] Me!

[The lights fade as the students crowd around the garden bed.]

📚 Words to Know

debate
A talk where people share different ideas and give reasons for them.
setting
Where and when a story or play takes place.
compromise
An agreement where each side gets part of what it wants.

🤔 Check Your Understanding

Choose an answer. You will see if it is right and why. You can look back at the passage any time.

Text feature1. In a play, what do the words in brackets, like [quietly], tell you?
Setting2. What is the setting of the play?
Problem and solution3. What problem do the students solve?
Key detail4. Why did Jada change her mind about pumpkins?
Vocabulary5. The class ends with a compromise. What is a compromise?
Character6. How does Ms. Okafor help the class decide?

✏️ Write About It

Write two more lines for this play. One student has a new idea for the garden. Use a character name, a colon, and one stage direction in brackets.

🔎 About This Story

This is an original story written for SmartOnlineGames. The characters and events are made up.

The grade band is our editors’ judgment based on sentence length, vocabulary and topic. It is not a Lexile or other formal reading-level measure.

🌟 Keep Reading