🔥 Heating Curve Lab: Ice to Steam

Particles · Heating curve graph · °C or °F · Grades 2–8

Try it and see: what happens when you heat ice?

Put a block of ice at −20 °C on a steady heater and watch two things at once: the particles inside, and a heating curve graph of temperature over time. The heater never changes, yet the temperature stops rising twice. Can you explain why?

Want to set the temperature yourself and sort solids, liquids and gases? Try the States of Matter particle game. This lab adds heat over time and graphs it.

🔥 Heating curve lab

Changing a setting starts a new run. Old runs stay on the graph as faint lines so you can compare.

Heating curve: temperature over time

This is a simplified model. The heater adds the same energy every second, and all of it goes into the water (a real pot loses some heat to the air). The container is closed, so the steam stays in and keeps warming. Energy values for water come from OpenStax and the University of Texas (see Sources). Heater settings are model numbers: low 250, medium 500 and high 1,000 joules per second.

🤔 Predict, test, explain

What scientists know

  • Ice melts at 0 °C (32 °F). Water boils at 100 °C (212 °F) at sea level (OpenStax; USGS).
  • Boiling point changes with height. At 5,000 feet, water boils at about 94.9 °C (202.9 °F). The higher you go, the lower the air pressure and the lower the boiling temperature (USGS).
  • Flat parts on the graph: while ice melts or water boils, the temperature stays the same. The added energy loosens or breaks the hold particles have on each other instead of making them move faster (OpenStax).
  • Boiling takes much more energy than melting. Melting 1 gram of ice takes about 334 joules. Boiling 1 gram of water into steam takes about 2,260 joules (University of Texas; OpenStax gives 2,256). That is why the boiling plateau is so long.
  • Water warms slowly. Water has a high specific heat: it absorbs a lot of heat before it gets hot (USGS). Liquid water needs about 4.18 joules to warm 1 gram by 1 °C, while ice and steam need only about 2 (University of Texas).

✅ Check yourself (5 questions)

🖨 Printable: heating curve worksheet

Read the lab's graph, label the solid, liquid and gas parts and the two plateaus, and explain where the energy goes.

For parents and teachers

NGSS MS-PS1-4: "Develop a model that predicts and describes changes in particle motion, temperature, and state of a pure substance when thermal energy is added or removed." The clarification stresses "qualitative molecular-level models of solids, liquids, and gases to show that adding or removing thermal energy increases or decreases kinetic energy of the particles until a change of state occurs," and lists water as an example pure substance (NGSS MS-PS1-4).

NGSS 2-PS1-4 (grade 2 link): "Construct an argument with evidence that some changes caused by heating or cooling can be reversed and some cannot." Its examples of reversible changes include "water and butter at different temperatures." Ask: if we cooled the steam, would we get water and then ice back? (NGSS 2-PS1-4).

  • Model: energy added = heater power × time. Ice warms with 2.09 J/g·°C, melts with 334 J/g, water warms with 4.184 J/g·°C, boils with 2,260 J/g, and steam warms with 2.03 J/g·°C (University of Texas heating curve notes). The run starts at −20 °C and stops 20 degrees above the boiling point.
  • At 5,000 feet the model only moves the boiling point to 94.9 °C (USGS). It keeps the same energy per gram for boiling, which is a small simplification.
  • Particle view: the dots are a picture of the idea, not real molecules. Dot speed grows with temperature, and dots switch state in proportion to how much of the melting or boiling energy has been added.
  • Common ideas to test: many students expect the temperature to keep rising as long as the heater is on, or think bubbles in boiling water are air. The flat plateaus are strong evidence to discuss.

Sources

We opened and checked each of these pages while writing this one.

Questions kids and teachers ask

Why does the temperature stop rising while ice melts?

The heat is still going in, but it is used to break the particles out of their fixed places in the ice instead of making them move faster. The temperature stays at 0 °C until all the ice has melted.

Why is the boiling part of the graph longer than the melting part?

Turning water into steam pulls the particles completely apart, which takes much more energy: about 2,260 joules per gram to boil, compared with about 334 joules per gram to melt.

Does water always boil at 100 °C?

Only at sea level. Higher up there is less air pressure, so water boils at a lower temperature. At 5,000 feet it boils at about 94.9 °C (202.9 °F).

How is this different from the States of Matter game?

In the States of Matter game you set the temperature with a slider. In this lab a heater adds energy over time, and you graph how the temperature changes, including the flat parts.